Thursday, November 23, 2006

Lee = Bad Idea

Signing Carlos Lee or Manny Ramirez would be like bringing back Bobby Abreu, but paying more for him. They only good thing about Lee is that he's right handed to bat between Howard and Utley. That doesn't make him that worth it. Buster Olney gives his reasons on why the Phillies would look like idiots.
And now, four months later, they are on the verge of signing another player who is A) roughly the same age (Abreu is 32, Lee is 30); B) much worse defensively, considering his range and throwing arm; C) an inferior athlete -- Lee's thickening body greatly concerns some general managers; and D) much, much, much more expensive, with the team's financial obligation for an impact corner outfielder increasing by perhaps as much as $85 million, if the Phillies' bid takes them over $100 million.
It's very Philly-like to easily look like an idiot for the front offices of our teams, but let's hope they don't take that route.

Happy Thanksgiving and please no family fights over Pat Gillick, Andy Reid, Allen Iverson, or any Philly sports personalities.

Link to the Buster Olney Blog if you got ESPN Insider

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

It does look pretty bad on the surface, but the thing is, the thing needed to rearranged with a new mix of players. That's nothing negative about Abreu, he was a great player and probably a great guy, but the current mix just wasn't working.

Anonymous said...

Oh, but I agree, Carlos Lee is a bad idea, but from what I hear, the Phils really do have zero interest in him, its just a rumor.

Old Fat Ted said...

But it's the definition of the front office flip-flopping on its agenda. Lee is less athletic and lazier than Abreu and he would get signed to a huge contract. Maybe with a new team he could play well, but is that chance worth a huge multi-year contract.

Anonymous said...

If the Phillies were actually interested in him, then it would be a flip flop. But they aren't [or I guess "weren't" is the operative word now], so it's not a flip flop.